PENANG, Malaysia -- Two years ago, Malaysian software engineer Terry Lim got
a phone call from a Singapore-based dot-com company offering him a juicy new
job. Soon, he got another call, then a third. He took the fourth offer, moved
across the border and doubled his income.
And still the headhunters keep ringing. "It's fabulous," Mr. Lim raves.
Not for people like O.K. Lee, the executive director of Toray Pen Group's
Malaysian unit. Mr. Lee wants experienced software designers to help automate
his petrochemical and fabric factories here, and to create the Internet
business-to-business capability the Japanese company's customers demand. But
just when he needs them most, engineers like Mr. Lim are increasingly hard to
find -- and even harder to keep.
"It's tough to find experienced people in Malaysia, and the market is getting
tighter," says Datuk Lee. To fill the jobs from within, he sent Toray's own
information-technology specialists for training to upgrade their skills. But
then the poachers moved in. "It's a real dilemma. Their market value goes up the
moment we train them," he laments. "We've lost 20% of our senior people in the
last year."
The country's skills gap is widening at a time when Malaysia is trying to
broaden its industrial base from assembly-oriented to higher valued-added
manufacturing. While the software engineer shortage is a global problem,
Malaysia feels the pinch more than regional rivals such as Hong Kong and
Singapore. Those countries are cherry-picking Malaysia's small pool of homegrown
talent with the promise of higher salaries in a more tech-savvy environment.
Malaysia's predicament: Until it becomes an innovation hub, its sharpest
young software experts won't stay home. But to be a tech hot spot, the country
first needs a critical mass of first-rate engineers. Mr. Lim, for example, says
he won't come back any time soon, despite plenty of offers from Malaysian
concerns. While money is a big issue, it's only part of Singapore's appeal. Mr.
Lim says he can learn more where companies are developing -- not simply
installing -- the latest technologies.
Desperate, Malaysian companies are starting to recruit information-technology specialists in India.
But there, too, they must compete with global electronics giants.
"This is a serious situation. Unless it's dealt with quickly, some of these
companies may decide to pack up and go," says Toh Kin Woon, the minister for
human resources and the economy in Penang state, Malaysia's electronics
manufacturing heartland. "It's all well to suggest our local factories move up
the value-added chain, to R&D and design, but first we need the skilled
labor."
Malaysia must adapt because it's fast losing its competitive edge as a cheap
place to assemble electronics goods. To hold down labor costs, Globetronics
Technology Bhd., a manufacturer of integrated circuit board components, now
imports 40% of its factory workers from Indonesia. Even so, competition for
experienced assembly-line employees in Penang's electronics plants is so intense
that some companies offer an immediate 10% pay raise to workers willing to leave
their current job.
To hasten a shift from assembly operations to more sophisticated production,
the Malaysian government is pursuing policies intended to create a "knowledge
economy."
Four years ago, the government began construction of the Multi-media Super
Corridor project near Kuala Lumpur. The corridor -- a hard-wired, high-tech
zone, complete with its own university, tax breaks and an array of other
investor lures -- is touted as Malaysia's answer to Silicon Valley. Kuala
Lumpur's 2001 budget adds more measures aimed at closing the skills gap,
including a revamped, tech-heavy school curriculum and funding for four new
universities and four new advanced technology training centers.
But some industry executives grumble that Malaysia got its priorities
reversed, focusing on education and labor issues only after it started to build
the super corridor. Tellingly, perhaps, the government has yet to survey
national supply-and-demand trends for IT workers. The Multi Media Development
Corp., a government-linked agency, estimates that companies in the super
corridor alone will need about 108,000 IT specialists by 2001, and most of those
companies want staff with at least two years' experience. In 1999, however,
Malaysian schools produced just 20,000 graduates with IT-related degrees or
diplomas.
Businesses are trying to help meet the demand. Local units of Siemens AG and
Motorola Inc., for example, have teamed up with Malaysian universities to help
design new technology programs. But neither those efforts nor the recent budget
measures will produce the experienced engineers companies need right now.
"Manufacturing companies that just didn't need this kind of staff a few years
ago now do, to install certain technologies. And without those technologies, a
company may grow slower or be less competitive with global players," says Mark
Chang, chief executive of Jobstreet.com, a Malaysia-based regional online
recruiter. Moreover, he adds, it's often hard to persuade a programmer to move
to small-town Penang to design software when he or she has offers from Singapore
or the U.S.
That's something understood well by Datuk Lee of Toray Pen -- whose
petrochemical factories produce materials used in printed circuits and plastic
injection molds. His own two sons, both software engineers, are working in the
U.S. and can't be tempted home. The attraction: being in a cutting-edge tech
environment while pulling down a hefty salary. A fresh computer-science graduate
can easily make $50,000 a year or more in Silicon Valley; in Malaysia, a
similarly trained grad earns about 30,000 ringgit, or just under $8,000. "Who
can blame them?" shrugs Datuk Lee.
Meanwhile, the Toray executive is scrambling to keep pace with the latest
technologies. He's in the process of installing an online business-to-business
capability for Toray's fabric business, which supplies U.S. retailers such as
J.C. Penney Co. and The Gap Inc. "We need to automate our business processes as
far as possible," Datuk Lee says. "The customers are demanding this."
He's prepared to pay more to deliver on those demands -- he's upped his IT
specialists' pay by about 25% in the past year -- but turnover is still
high.
Indeed, industry executives say poaching is rampant in Penang. Zip-drive
maker Iomega (Malaysia) Sdn. Bhd. -- a unit of U.S.-based Iomega Corp. -- has
lost eight programmers to a Penang-based subsidiary of Dell Computer Corp. in
the past seven months. Joe Adams, an Iomega vice president, says he's spent
$20,000 to $30,000 each to send about a dozen staffers to the U.S. over the past
two years to be trained by Oracle Corp. But when the trained workers return,
other Malaysia-based multinationals try to poach them. "Sometimes it's more
expedient to pinch these people," says an exasperated Mr. Adams.
Local companies -- which can't compete with multinationals that offer big
salaries and stock options -- are now forced to look overseas for skilled
staff.
The quest for programmers took a team from Globetronics, the Malaysian
components maker, to India. Globetronics created a subsidiary earlier this year
to provide electronic-business services, and it needed six programmers to get
the company off the ground. But competition forced the Malaysians to bypass key
technology centers such as Bangalore and search for staff in small software
companies on the outskirts of New Delhi. "All the big boys are there, too -- in
terms of dollars and cents, we certainly can't compete," says Ng Kok Choon,
corporate planning manager.
Globetronics's new subsidiary is sited in the super corridor, which made
getting work visas for its Indian programmers easier than it is for most
companies. Malaysia allows super-corridor-status concerns to import all the
foreign experts they need and expedites the visa application process, which
otherwise can take weeks or months to complete. But for manufacturers based
elsewhere, the visa process can pose big headaches.
"The process for them seems to be the first application gets rejected, then
you have to appeal," says Dr. Toh, the minister for human resources and the
economy in Penang state, who gets regular calls for help from Penang-based
manufacturers who've been stonewalled by Malaysian immigration officials. "It
can be pretty frustrating for them."
Ultimately, however, attracting technology experts in a global labor market
will depend on companies' own priorities. "Companies are just going to beef up
on efficiencies and lower other costs so they can afford to pay what it takes to
attract these people," says David Gee, vice president of ENG Teknologi Holdings
Bhd., which makes hard-disk drive components. "Otherwise, it's going to be
pretty bleak."
At Toray Pen, Datuk Lee has begun offering monthly bonuses to key staff, on
top of pay raises, as an incentive to stay. And Iomega offers a twice-yearly
performance-linked bonus that often adds up to an extra three months' pay.
"The prospects of the country depend on the quality of the human resources,"
says Datuk Lee. "If we miss out now, we'll fall further
behind."