Editors note: The interview excerpts reconstructed here are real, but
candidates and interviewers names have been changed at their request.
Mike Weldon, a project manager with 10 years experience in telecommunications,
was interviewing for a job as project director with a large cellular communications
company in the Midwest. He felt confident and prepared for his meeting with Dan Crane,
senior vice president of the engineering division, who immediately asked some tough
questions.
Dan: I reviewed your resume and found your background impressive. What
can you do for us?
Mike: Ive recently been involved in a large-scale project aimed at
linking our mainframes to a satellite telecommunications system over the Atlantic to
improve teleconferencing capabilities with Europe.
Dan: I see. While that sounds interesting, Im more concerned with your
ability to handle multiple projects for us covering our domestic locations in Chicago, New
York, Dallas and Minneapolis. Our project deadline is only two months from now.
Mike: Thats a pretty quick turnaround. I had no idea.
Dan: Thats my top priority. Think you can handle it?
Mike: Well, I think so. But Ill need more information. Could you-- (Dan
interrupts)
Dan: If its resources youre asking for, Ive got to be honest
with you. Were running lean in our department. We had some deep budget cuts last
year, and theyve been carried over to this year. Youll have to do more with
less, Im afraid.
Mike: I understand. Can I tell you about my experience with the build-outs of
several data centers in Denver not long ago?
Dan: How long ago?
Mike: Well, it was in spring 1988 and-- (Dan interrupts)
Dan: Wow. Thats 10 years ago. Technology has changed quite a bit since
then, especially the way it affects how projects are managed. Were you the project leader?
Mike: Uh, no. I was part of a team of eight people and-- (Dan interrupts)
Dan: (annoyed and very direct) Look, I have to be straight with you. I need a
hands-on manager who can handle large projects and has cutting-edge knowledge and skills
with very sophisticated state-of-the-art technology. Im accountable for a specific
number of deliverables during this year, and I need a strong self-starter. Do you have any
questions?
Mike: Uh, no. Not right now.
Dan: OK, then. Thanks for coming in. Ill be in touch.
Waiting for the elevator, an unhappy Mike wished he could have talked about helping his
boss achieve all of his objectives ahead of schedule or the special training he received
on managing multi-level projects. But he couldnt get this information out because
Dan "ran the show."
Sometimes seemingly well-qualified job applicants interview poorly because they
didnt ask the right questions early in the interview--questions that would relate
their skills, knowledge and experience to the job and hiring managers needs. When
Dan said he wanted someone to manage multiple projects, Mike should have quickly asked,
"Could you explain some of the important objectives and details of these
projects?" or "Can you describe in detail the directors role in this
job?" Mike probably would have been better able to address Dans concerns and
turn the interview into a discussion between peers.
This is the "inquiry approach" to interviewing. It helps applicants because
they immediately can ask questions about the job, managements expectations, company
culture and the current strategic plan for the department, division or company. This
information is critical because hiring managers want to learn during interviews if
youll be an asset to their organizations.
"When we coach candidates, we tell them to use a consultative approach to the
interview," says Kate Wendleton, president of the Five OClock Club, a New
York-based career-management consulting firm. "We want them to be more proactive and
get a thorough understanding of the organization and its current concerns by asking
pertinent questions right away."
Be Ready to Ask
In an inquiry interview, you must be ready to ask questions at appropriate times during
the interview. Prepare questions in advance that relate to general concerns about your
career path and company finances, products, services and other business areas.
"I advise clients to ask questions as early in the interview as possible to find
out about the company culture, communication protocols and personality fit for
the position," says Carol Goldin, president of Gramercy Search, an executive-search
firm in New York and a former vice president of human resources at the Bank of Tokyo.
"When I was with the bank, I encouraged applicants to ask me questions almost
immediately."
You also must be able to think of questions spontaneously. After an interviewer
comments about job content, a managers goals, work environment, changes in
leadership or other business issues, ask probing questions to get more information.
You can also answer an awkward or tough question with a question of your own to deflect
or redirect the interviewer.
By asking the right questions at the right time, youll get information that will
help you give interviewers better answers and convince them youre suitable for the
job. It also helps you and the interviewer decide if youre a good match.
Listen and Probe
From the start of an interview, listen carefully. If you need to take notes, ask
permission. Respond to the first question youre asked, and then pose a relevant
question to the interviewer.
Listen carefully to the interviewers response. Probe for more information about
the response or ask another follow-up question.
As appropriate throughout the interview, respond with statements that link your
background and experience to the interviewers stated needs.
In closing, ask the interviewer, "Is there anything else youd like to
cover?" By this time, youll have addressed topics and issues important to both
of you and had a meaningful meeting.
Asking the Right Questions
Before the interview, prepare such questions about general business issues as:
- What are your three most important strategic objectives for this year?
- Describe the role Id play in this position.
- Is this a new position or would I replace someone?
- Is there a career path for this position?
- Can you outline the organizational structure in this department? Division?
- What are your companys key competitive concerns?
- Describe the corporate culture.
- Why did you join this organization?
- Describe the companys leadership. Whats their short- and long-term vision?
- Describe the ideal candidate for this position.
Here are examples of how you can use these questions in an interview.
Recovering From a Rough Start
Sue Colbert was interviewing for a position as head buyer for a national retailer
selling kitchenware and culinary products at 200 stores. Heres how she expertly
handled what could have been a rough start with interviewer Pam Smythe, her prospective
boss (who, incidentally, didnt have time to read Sues resume thoroughly).
Pam: Let me first tell you that this is going to be a difficult job.
Youll have 21 assistant buyers reporting to you, most of whom work in other cities
across the country. Youll be responsible for a huge volume of merchandise and there
will be a great deal of travel required, about 80%. Now, I dont see experience on
your resume that suggests youre up for this.
Sue: Youve exactly hit upon the issue Id like to discuss further.
And I want to draw some relevant comparisons between my career accomplishments along these
lines and your current goals. Could you describe your strategic plan for this year? I can
then better explain how I can help you meet that plan. And just what are your three most
important goals?
Pam: First, I need to cut purchasing costs by 20% while keeping the quality of
our merchandise high. Second, I am responsible for eliminating 30 of our current stores
and replacing them with 30 upscale, specialty stores featuring merchandise for the
professional commercial marketplace. I have to select the appropriate 30 to be replaced.
Third, I have to expand our buying capacity to the Asian and European markets. Our
international product lines currently come from Central and South America exclusively.
Sue: What percentage of merchandise comes from those countries?
Pam: About 30% to 35%.
Sue: When I was a buyer for Epicure Ltd., I created a business strategy to
cost effectively purchase quality kitchen accessories from Germany, Italy and Spain. As a
result, we increased our customer base by 28% in the public consumer market and 15% in the
professional culinary market. Pam, would you like to see a business plan? I can have one
faxed to you early next week.
Pam: Sure. Id very much like to see it. Tell me more about your
experience at Epicure Ltd.
Sue elaborated on her experience as a professional buyer and did well in the interview.
She managed to turn the interview around by asking key questions immediately. In short,
she hit Pams "hot button" (her three strategic objectives) and got her
attention. Sues offer to send Pam a business plan piqued Pams interest in
Sues experience. From that point, Sue was able to make the interview a win-win
situation.
Finding Important Clues
Ted Alvarez was interviewing for a job as assistant general manager of a large hotel in
New York. He spoke with Gordon Leighton, the hotels general manager.
Gordon: Ted, Id like to find out more about you and your experience,
especially in Singapore at the Raffles Hotel. But first let me explain to you what
Im looking for. I need a strong, right-hand person to manage this large facility,
the main dining room and housekeeping, in particular. We have 945 rooms here, and the last
person who held this position literally thought he was on a perpetual vacation. It amazed
me how he just didnt understand what it meant, or for that matter what it took, to
achieve and maintain the level of excellence which we require here.
Ted (responding quickly): That brings up a pertinent point. What is the ideal
candidate for this position?
Gordon: I require someone who will do whatever it takes to satisfy our guests
and who is 110% dedicated to the service of this hotel. I would love to find a person who
is tireless in the performance of the many duties he or she will be expected to
accomplish. That individual must also be on call virtually 24 hours a day. And this is
above and beyond the flexibility one must have to accommodate the well-known demands of
our industry.
Ted (sizing up Gordon as a difficult boss): Can you describe your management
style?
Gordon: Im a stickler for details, and, as you no doubt know, one must
pay attention to every detail. I also need to be kept informed of your activities.
Thats why I require a very close reporting relationship between us, should you be
selected for this position. Also, while Im not one to give the proverbial pat
on the back for a job well done, Ill let you know very clearly when you
havent performed according to expectations.
Ted was uncomfortable with this response and decided not to pursue the position. His
first clue had been Gordons negative comment about the previous manager. Ted then
began asking questions that would elicit information to help him decide whether to pursue
the job.
Handling the Prober
There are additional ways to use questions during interviews. Some interviewers will
repeatedly ask you about a single issue and relentlessly probe your responses to identify
inconsistencies or problem areas in your background. The "inquiry approach"
helps you to curtail the probe and change the direction of an interviewers
questions.
Interviewer: How did you get along with your boss?
Applicant: Fine. We agreed on just about everything when it came to running
the business.
Interviewer: Well, just what did you differ on? (a probe)
Applicant: Well, I guess the strategies involving sales development.
Interviewer: Can you elaborate? (another probe)
Instead of being forced to describe the differences, which would invite more probes,
the applicant responds with a question:
Applicant: As a hallmark of my management style Im very flexible and
accommodating and very rarely revert to conflict. But to help me understand the way things
work around here, can you tell me how the company culture operates to resolve conflict,
should it occur?
This question deflects the probe and redirects the interview to a topic which is still
related to the interviewers question but less penetrating and incisive for the
applicant.
Sticky Questions
Heres another interview situation where asking a question can help you escape a
tough question.
Interviewer: How much money are you looking for?
Applicant: (very calmly and with light humor): Gee, I wasnt expecting to
discuss money at this point, but Im curious how much youre offering for a
position at this level, considering someone with my background and experience. Can you
give me a ballpark figure or maybe a range?
Simply turn the tables and ask what interviewers would normally ask. Most of the time,
interviewers will accommodate you.
Applicant
: Im really not ready to discuss money until Ive learned more
about the job and determine how closely my knowledge, skills and experience match the job
requirements. Can we defer compensation until later in the interview?
Your Final Question
Some applicants are uncomfortable at the end of an interview because they arent
sure if they should ask more questions. Its also disconcerting when interviewers
dont indicate if they intend to invite the applicant for a second interview.
Heres a way to gauge interviewers impressions of you and learn if they intend
to pursue you.
Applicant
: I really enjoyed our conversation. Do you think well have another
meeting soon?
Sound Advice
Practice the "inquiry approach" with a colleague or friend to become
comfortable with the strategy. Ask non-threatening questions that will elicit information
about the job, management style, corporate culture and the companys strategic plan.
When interviewers respond to your questions, always show that youre listening.
Youll make interviewers comfortable and stay in control during the meeting.
-- Mr. Artise is a senior consultant with Partners in Human
Resources International, a human-resources consulting firm in New York.
The Benefits of Asking
If you ask the right questions during an interview, youll get information that
will help you provide better responses to employers questions. The inquiry approach
also:
- Draws out information about the managers strategic plan.
- Helps you make a good impression with your questions and shows youre interested.
- Gets sluggish interviewers to talk more.
- Draws interviewers attention to relevant experiences they hadnt considered.
- Allows you to probe unclear responses.
- Redirects interviewers so theyll ask questions you prefer to answer.
- Deflects excessive probing about a single issue.