One of the first things Joel Collamer did after being laid off from Cap
Gemini Ernst & Young in July 2001 was e-mail 10 colleagues who had also
lost their jobs. He was setting up a private group on Yahoo.com for them to
keep in touch. He wrote: "This can help us stick together and trade job
leads."
A virtual networking group was born.
Today, 40 senior-level executives with technology and insurance industry
expertise are plugged into Mr. Collamer's group, dubbed "Collamer's
Connections." One member lives as far north as Maine, another as far west
as Iowa; most have never met face to face. But they regularly trade
industry news, contacts and tips about job openings. So far six have found
jobs as a result of the network's help, says Mr. Collamer, who lives in
Greenwich, Conn.
In prior downturns, unemployed workers relied solely on personal
networks, recruiters and cold calls to prospective employers. This time,
the unemployed have a new resource to harness: the Internet. As a result,
the current tough job market has seen a wave of people creating or
enlisting in online networks to share job information.
After recent massive layoffs at companies such as Enron Corp. and Global
Crossing Ltd., for instance, ex-employees set up Web sites to stay
connected and share company news about such matters as severance payments.
Many smaller online networks, meanwhile, are geared toward job seekers and
often targeted to professions or regions.
A.J. Lawrence, a 33-year-old New Yorker, formed a group called NYC Job
Search in July. Mr. Lawrence was laid off last November as a director of
business development at Daedalus Technology Group, a New York technology
consulting company. The group's 20 members trade information and job leads
through a Yahoo group; several members also meet weekly in coffee shops to
discuss their progress. "This was a method of trying to talk to other
people and say, how are you going about your job search? Is there a better
way?" says Mr. Lawrence.
Another New York-based group called WeWantWork.com, formed in August, has garnered publicity for its street rallies,
in which members wear sandwich boards and pass out flyers about the
organization. But the group's 43 members mainly keep in touch with one
another and pass job leads online.
Gayle Snible, who was laid off from a public relations job a year ago,
says she receives between five and 10 e-mails a day from the group. "Some
are anecdotes about job searches, and some are hard job leads," she says.
Ms. Snible, 35, recently started a part-time marketing position she
discovered through the network.
Some career experts remain skeptical about the value of virtual groups
where members never meet in person. "Basically it's too impersonal," says
Richard Bayer, chief operating officer of The Five O'Clock Club, a
career-coaching and outplacement firm based in New York. "Networking is
something that is a little more 'high touch.' "
Indeed, the groups struggle to stay useful. For instance, many carefully
vet applicants before letting them join. Mr. Collamer personally interviews
people who ask to sign on, occasionally asking for a resume, and cautions
prospective members that they're obligated to contribute to the group.
Mr. Lawrence, who has been freer about accepting people into his
fledgling network, has already had to kick one person out. "He was
demanding stuff ... just being belligerent," Mr. Lawrence says.
Yet members say that even the relative strangers who belong to virtual
networks provide emotional support in addition to job leads.
"One of the great values besides the job leads is not feeling terminally
unique," says Greg Black, a 45-year-old Nashville, Tenn., resident and
member of Mr. Collamer's network who has been hunting for a job since June.
"You get a greater sense of loyalty from a virtual group like this than
from most employers."