July 9, 2004 -- FRANKFURT -- After four years of economic stagnation and political
squabbling, Germany has acquired a reputation as a country stuck in its
ways when it comes to restructuring the welfare state. But today, its
parliament is expected to pass the country's deepest cut in social benefits
in half a century.
Officials expect a majority in Germany's upper house to approve --
across party lines -- a sharp reduction of generous state benefits for the
long-term unemployed, a step aimed at pushing the jobless back to work. The
lower house approved the measure last week.
The initiative is part of a package of changes proposed by the Social
Democrat-led government of Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder meant to increase
employment, restore economic growth and put the nation's welfare state on
sounder financial footing. The measures, which have split Mr. Schroeder's
party and led him to step down as its chairman, go beyond the more-modest
abatements of other euro-zone economies, except for the Netherlands'
changes in the 1990s. France has made some progress on reworking state
pensions and is debating health-care changes, but voter backlash has
prompted the government to shift its energy to protecting jobs and
increasing consumption to spur growth. In Italy, political disunity and
fiscal disarray have delayed the government's ambitious tax-cutting
agenda.
Until now, a German who hasn't worked for more than a year receives
unemployment benefits at 53% of his most recent net wage, plus supplements
for local and family circumstances, for an unlimited period. The new law
would replace this with a flat rate of €345 per month ($426), plus
rent and family supplements -- the same as the minimal-relief check given
to the poor. The change means many unemployed stand to lose hundreds of
euros a month.
Job centers responsible for the new system will be able to suspend or
partially withhold payments if recipients turn down job offers. But people
who find low-paying work can continue to receive some or all of these
payments.
Economics minister Wolfgang Clement calls it "the most significant and
comprehensive labor-market reform in the history of the Federal Republic."
Many economists say Germany's proposals, dubbed "Agenda 2010," will fall
short of restoring economic dynamism. After three years of nearly no growth, economists believe German
output will grow by 1.8% this year, mainly thanks to surging exports.
Domestic demand remains weak. Data from German manufacturers show that
orders from abroad rose 4.1% from April to May as the global economy
improved, but domestic orders fell 0.6%.
"Even the highest pressure on the unemployed won't work if there are no
jobs," says Eckart Tuchfeld, an economist at Commerzbank in Frankfurt. "The
measures are a good first step, but more are needed. Some positive effects
will become tangible, but they won't be enough to really improve economic
growth." To help create more jobs, he says, the government would have to
allow employers more flexibility on industrywide wage levels, job security
and working hours, and cut state health and pension levies on
employment.
German employers long have advocated such measures, but labor unions
already strongly oppose the government's existing steps as socially unjust.
Last weekend, former party members and labor unionists -- who traditionally
have backed the Social Democrats -- launched preparations for a new
left-wing political party to challenge the government in elections. Unions
have organized mass rallies against Mr. Schroeder this year, and the Social
Democrats received their lowest-ever share of a national vote in last
month's Europe-wide elections.
Ministers admit ordinary Germans haven't accepted the measures, but
argue that there is no other way to make the country's welfare system
affordable as the population ages. Labor-market changes already enacted
include exempting more low-paying jobs from health and pension levies,
turning offices that administer the dole into job centers modeled on those
in the U.K., and making it cheaper for small businesses to lay off staff in
bad times.
The government also has sought to bring the present and long-term costs
of state health and pension provisions under control. This year it has
limited the number of prescription drugs covered by state health insurance
-- a step the government says already has saved more than €1
billion -- and introduced a €10 fee per quarter for visiting a
doctor or dentist.
Pension changes enacted so far include removing tax incentives for early
retirement, limiting state pension levels to keep employees' contributions
below 20% of their wages and introducing a link between raises in state
pensions and the ratio of workers to pensioners. But a much-heralded
subsidy for government-approved private pension savings, introduced in
2002, proved too restrictive and fewer Germans than hoped have taken up the
offer.
In a quest to stimulate growth, the government also has cut income taxes
for individuals and businesses, by a total of €15 billion in 2004
and €6.5 billion next year. But German consumers, worried by job
insecurity and welfare changes, show little inclination to spend more.