After enduring what is widely considered the worst downturn in
its more than 50-year history, the U.S. executive-recruiting industry is
starting to look up.
For many companies, a turnaround in the industry that started
last year is gaining momentum. Half of the largest 25 executive search firms, by
revenue, saw sales growth last year, according to industry consultants
Hunt-Scanlon Advisers in Stamford, Conn. Four companies enjoyed double-digit
increases, including Slayton International Inc., whose revenue jumped 75.1%, and
Morgan Samuels Co., where revenue grew 31%.
At some companies, the recent increase in business amounts to a
sea change. Between 2000 and 2002, the widespread slowdown in hiring ravaged an
industry that had been riding high in the "war for talent" late-1990s, and
hundreds of small recruiting companies went out of business. Numerous bigger
firms hunkered down by shutting offices and cutting staffs. Thousands of
individual recruiters were forced out of jobs.
"There's been a tremendous shakeout in the search industry,"
says David Hoffmann, chief executive officer of Chicago-based DHR International
Inc., the fifth-largest search firm by revenue. The firm's revenue rose 13.6% in
2003. In Mr. Hoffmann's view, hiring has picked up even more dramatically this
year, and he boasts that his company's revenue in the first quarter was up 50%
over the same period last year. The company is in the process of opening its
eighth new office this year. "I think we're in a very significant up cycle in
hiring," he says.
Most firms are optimistic that they will continue to see a
modest boost in business this year. According to Hunt-Scanlon, 78% of big
executive search firms expect to see revenue growth this year of 6% to 8%. Yet
many wonder whether these levels will be sustainable. "The big question is
whether this recovery is going to last beyond 2004," says Brian Lee, chief
market strategist for Hunt-Scanlon. "A lot of this is pent-up hiring that hasn't
taken place over the last two years. Companies are so thinly staffed that
finally they're doing some strategic hiring."
Recruiting firms are hiring as well. Many companies that
outsourced research and candidate-development work during the downturn are now
finding it more cost-effective to have that work done in-house as search volumes
increase. A survey of recruiters in April by Norwalk, Conn.-based ExecuNet,
which provides career and other resources to executives and recruiters, found
that 43% of search firms planned to hire in the next three months. During the
prior three months, 23% of firms had increased their staffs.
Here is a look at some sectors that are enjoying increases in
hiring and helping bolster the recruiting industry.
Board and CEO searches. Corporate scandals and resulting
governance changes, including those required by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, have
increased demand for new executives at the highest levels. Some search firms
weathered the downturn better by focusing on CEO and board searches. Others,
including Los Angeles-based Korn/Ferry International, have
recently turned more attention to these searches as the demand has continued to
grow. "That's part of the firm's strategy -- to increase the number of board and
CEO searches," says Joseph Griesedieck, Korn/Ferry vice chairman. "I have seen a
lot of uptick in those areas."
Financial services. "The last couple of years has been a
replacement market, and we're back into an addition market," says John Rogan,
head of the financial-services-sector practice at Russell Reynolds Associates in
New York. Financial-services searches at the firm are up 40% this year over the
same period last year, with investment-banking searches increasing 70%,
according to Mr. Rogan. "No one in the market has indicated that there's any
immediate slowdown coming," he says.
Consumer products. Recruiters say better quarterly
results and an increase in capital investments at companies in this sector have
started to translate into more management openings. "We have seven main sectors,
and consumer products has been near the top," says Dave Campeas, president and
CEO of Princeton Search Group/MRI, based in Princeton, N.J. He says the firm has
done between 80 and 90 searches for consumer-products companies since January, a
25% increase over the same period last year. The firm has hired 25 consultants
since January, a 14% increase.
Corporate communications. Corporate scandals have
affected jobs here as well. "They have made it so that companies need to pay
special attention to people that are attending to their corporate reputation,"
says Bill Heyman, president and CEO of Heyman Associates Inc. in New York. The
firm handles searches for managers mostly at the vice-president level and above
who head up communications departments. Last year, the 16-employee firm handled
54 such searches, up from 33 the prior year. It has also brought on three
staffers since the beginning of the year.