Reference checking is a standard part of the hiring process, but it is not always easy
to get references to speak. Sometimes it's because they are afraid their former employee
will sue them if they divulge something the employee wanted kept secret. Other times, the
reference may feel that saying as little as possible is the more prudent course. No one
wants to be responsible for a candidate's missing out on a job.
Although former employers are justifiably concerned about liability, "there are no
specific statutes governing reference checking," says Lewis Silverman, a partner at
Jackson, Lewis, Schnitzler & Krupman, a White Plains, N.Y.-based national law firm
specializing in employment law. Some states, such as Florida, have laws protecting
reference-givers, stating they cannot be sued for information provided in reference
checks. Other states are expected to follow suit.
For the potential new employer, federal employment laws guide the way. "The law
says you can't discriminate on the basis of race, religion, color, sex, or national
origin. You can't ask questions designed to elicit a candidate's age, race, or issues of
that nature," Mr. Silverman says.
For the in-house recruiter, of course, the goal is to hire the most qualified person,
and weed out undesirable candidates. The basis for making this decision is generally the
information garnered from (sometimes tight-lipped) references.
Mr. Silverman offers seven tips to break down that wall of silence and encourage a
reference to speak.
1. Use a reference release form. The form says that the employee has applied for a job
with your company, and releases and discharges the former employer from all claims
resulting from the information the employee discloses.
2. Expect reluctance when asking for information beyond what is included in the
reference-release form. One way to win the reference-giver's confidence is to demonstrate
discretion and thoroughness in checking references. Then, when you need him or her to
extrapolate on a point or two, he or she will be more forthcoming.
3. Carefully phrase questions that elicit a response. You might say, "Ms. X has
applied for a job at our firm and I'd appreciate it if you clarify a few items not covered
in our release form." If you experience extreme reluctance, you might try asking a
direct, all-inclusive question such as, "If this person reapplied for a job at your
firm right now, would you hire him?"
Ask to meet your counterpart in person if they are reluctant to provide information
over the phone. The HR community in many areas is small, allowing an in-person
tension-free interaction. A half-hour chat will not only allay the other pro's fears, but
also opens doors for further contact. This tactic is strongly recommended for important
hires.
5. Converse in person with prior employers particularly for jobs in certain industries.
These industries include safety-sensitive fields, such as healthcare, teaching, building
services or for virtually any position involving a high degree of contact with the public.
Taking the extra step is worth the effort.
6. Be attentive to the way your questions are answered. Listen for hesitancy in
responses. Does the reference protest too much, or damn by faint praise?
7. Remember, reference checking is just one step in the process. Certain positions
require an investigative background check to see if the candidate has any criminal
convictions.