When job hunting, one size definitely doesn't fit all.
Career counselors agree that job-search success begins with being
yourself. "The only way you'll do a job search successfully is your own
way," says California consultant and author Howard Figler. The trick is
discovering what your own way is and pursuing it efficiently.
Most candidates' job-search styles fall into one of four discernible
patterns. Each style presents a unique group of assets and liabilities. By
making your strengths the centerpiece of your search, you'll achieve better
results. And by developing compensating skills that minimize your defects,
you're less likely to sabotage your efforts.
To determine the style that suits you best, complete the adjacent
exercise. Then read on to identify strategies based on your results that
will help you search most successfully.
The Commander Style
Focused, results-oriented and proactive, Commanders are strategic
planners who specify long-range goals and move quickly to implement them.
Based on recent surveys, approximately 50% of all managers fit this
pattern. Competitiveness and competence are core motivators for Commanders,
but they're easily tripped up by unforeseen details, and can intimidate
others by their combative spirit. If they take their style to extremes,
they tend to alienate others.
Commanders prefer to chart a logical course and aren't afraid to make
"command decisions" based on the best available information. They know that
even the most effective decision-makers are wrong some of the time. When
Commanders fail, it's usually because they don't take interpersonal
amenities seriously and end up being too direct for their own good.
Faced with an unexpected job loss, Commanders don't waste time
reflecting, instead moving quickly to action. Their core strategies include
assessing the market objectively and dispassionately, identifying industry
niches likely to yield a quick return on their investment of time and
effort, and competing against deadlines they set for themselves.
Commanders often need reminders that employment decisions are made on
the basis of personal rapport and chemistry, and that not all obstacles
yield to a direct onslaught. Used to quick results, they typically find
life in the trenches difficult. Career transition provides Commanders with
opportunities to learn patience, trust and empathy.
The Adventurer Style
Optimistic, sociable and comfortable with risk describes Adventurers,
who make up about 25% of all managers. Such candidates like to jump in the
pool and get things going, with or without a plan. Usually motivated by
opportunities to bargain, persuade others and take chances, Adventurers
need to avoid depending more on salesmanship than competence. An
out-of-balance Adventurer can easily become all sizzle and no steak.
Eager to shake things up and make things happen, Adventurers are skilled
networkers, relationship-builders and enthusiasm-generators. Aware of the
importance of personal contacts and reciprocal obligations, most
Adventurers are effective, charismatic deal-makers who find details boring.
A stalled job search is usually triggered by an inattention to
particulars.
An Adventurer's search often begins within hours of losing a job, with
informal phone calls to everyone in his or her extensive personal network.
Their career objectives can be vague at the start of a campaign, but
quickly take shape as they discuss their situation with others.
Interactivity, a willingness to engage in tactical negotiations and a
reliance on emerging possibilities are their strategic strengths.
Adventurers may need help presenting a focused image to others.
Energized by possibilities, they often confuse action with progress and may
struggle with establishing realistic priorities. Consistency,
follow-through and avoidance of excessive risk are lessons they can draw
from the career-transition process.
The Systematizer Style
Detail-mindedness, tolerance of routine and a methodical orientation
characterize Systematizers. Candidates in this sector, who comprise about
20% of all managers, typically adopt a conventional, step-by-step approach
to job hunting that's strong in follow-through, attention to specifics and
personal accountability. They're motivated by following a proven,
established system to the letter. However, they may be waylaid by a lack of
imagination and difficulties in seeing possibilities outside of their
direct experience. If not tempered by balancing characteristics, the
Systematizer style can cause a job seeker to miss the forest for the
trees.
Systematizers often emphasize traditional, low-risk approaches, such as
answering help-wanted ads. Once they select a strategy, their reliability
and discipline often carry the day as they impress employers with their
stability. Job-search difficulties often stem from their failure to
recognize when directional changes are warranted. Unfortunately, their
persistence can easily become counterproductive if they adhere to outmoded
advice.
Systematizers can be expected to approach a job search in a structured
fashion. They'll carefully and comprehensively research pertinent employers
within their geographic target area, meticulously follow through and
maintain detailed records of their progress.
Career help for Systematizers involves expanding their targets outside
of their original base of experience. Identifying new ideas and
possibilities can be tough, compounded by their habitual risk-aversion and
mistrust of unproven approaches. Their goals should include identifying
their transferable skills and working on networking to increase their
self-confidence.
The Harmonizer Style
Only about 5% of managers are Harmonizers, although this style is more
common among certain occupational groups. Traits include idealism,
creativity and empathy. Focusing on personal values or an internal vision,
which they link to economically viable careers, is an important career
strength for Harmonizers.
These candidates seek to live in accordance with their personal
priorities and persist in steering by this inner compass, even in the face
of formidable obstacles. Career difficulties generally center around their
failure to moderate idealistic values and temper them with adequate doses
of reality. Unless held in check, these tendencies make Harmonizers seem
out of touch with the competitive marketplace.
A good starting point for a Harmonizer's job search is a thorough
self-assessment that restores awareness of, and faith in, core values. They
should consider a list of career options and related sources of income,
both conventional and entrepreneurial. They can gain motivation by
envisioning long-range possibilities that will allow them to make a
significant difference in a chosen field.
Most Harmonizers find it difficult to identify meaningful steps that
will lessen the gap between their ideals and the realities of the job
market, and may need help building credentials and maintaining an income
without sacrificing their core values.
Utilizing the Four Styles
Aaron King shows how all four styles can be used when balanced
effectively. A Commander by temperament, Mr. King (not his real name) was
outplaced from his middle-management manufacturing job due primarily to
communication differences with his boss. He initially wanted to leap into
the job market using his Commander strengths, but instead was challenged to
look inward first to learn from past experiences.
Shifting to this opposite, Harmonizer pattern was difficult at first,
but he recognized the opportunity to challenge himself in an untried area.
He soon found this activity surprisingly motivating. His analytical
abilities prompted him to identify several specific improvements he could
make in how he communicates with others, which he practiced to yield
positive results.
Moving next into a Systematizer role, Mr. King researched employers
comprehensively within his geographic circle. He began with industries and
functions in his career background, but despite a rigorous and meticulous
effort, he uncovered few good opportunities. Rather than become blocked by
this obstacle, he switched gears again and adopted an open-ended Adventurer
stance.
Mr. King used his personal network to glean new ideas from contacts who
knew him well, and he was surprised to find heavy support among them for a
switch to consulting. Exploring that possibility heightened his conviction
that it would be a rational career change for him. By marketing his
industry experience and transferable skills in this new arena using his
Commander strengths, he quickly landed a position at an equivalent salary
with a respected Wisconsin consulting firm.
Your job-search style may not fit neatly into one of these four
categories, but you'll likely be more comfortable with some styles than
others. Seek a balance by practicing skills related to your least familiar
style, beginning with safe tasks and then more challenging applications. In
a world where personal career management is essential, heighten your
effectiveness by identifying and leveraging your chosen style.
Dr. Embree is a counselor and consultant with
the Career Development Group in Mosinee, Wis.