Your resume is polished. Youre interviewing and networking. But the offers
arent coming in or the right companies arent offering. Or maybe youve
just started a new job and wonder if youve made the biggest mistake of your career.
Are you doing something wrong?
Probably not. In both cases, your setbacks may not be your fault. More likely,
its employers who are to blame. Often, when companies recruit from outside, they use
hiring practices that are no longer effective.
Your job search will be more successful if youre aware of these potential
pitfalls and adjust your strategy to correct for them. The following are the five most
common hiring mistakes employers make and strategies to help make them work to your
advantage.
When an employer doesnt define the job correctly, you may not get a full
understanding of the position and whats expected. Or, you may be qualified for the
job though your qualifications won't show it. If you accept the position, you may
experience problems because your responsibilities overlap others' or whats expected
of you is unclear.
Strategy: Interview with several managers from various departments, not just with
human resources or the employers search firm. In addition, meet your potential
subordinates and peers. Write down performance requirements or job expectations that seem
unclear and share them with your potential boss. Rewrite the job description to eliminate
points of confusion. If the employer is unable or unwilling to clarify the job
description, think twice before pursuing an offer.
Lets say your style is to consider every option and analyze all available data
before making decisions. As you meet the executives of a potential employer, however, you
discover that they embrace a "ready, aim, fire" philosophy of management. You
may be well qualified for the position but dont match the company culture.
Strategy: If the employer hasnt discussed its culture during the interview
process, you should bring it up. Ask to meet a cross-section of potential peers and
superiors to discuss their views on life in the company. Does your style mesh with that of
the people you meet?
Ask about employees who have joined the company and failed. Find out why they failed
and how long they stayed. Ask what types of professionals are attracted to the company,
including clients. Youll spend most of your waking hours working for this employer.
Be sure this is where you want to spend your time.
You were one of the employers top three candidates after the last round of
interviews, but two weeks have passed and you still havent heard a word. Youve
learned the position is still open, but the employer doesnt seem to be in as big a
hurry to hire as it was during the interviews.
Strategy: Help the employer maintain its sense of urgency by following up in a way
that isnt overbearing. Send e-mail or voice-mail messages to keep the employer
apprised of your other opportunities. Dont be afraid to ask if youre out of
the running. You may not like the answer, but you can move on with a clearer idea of your
options.
When you receive an offer, let other companies youve interviewed with know as
soon as possible. Not only is this a courtesy, but you just might prompt them to make you
an offer.
The employer is so focused on choosing the "perfect" candidate that it
cant hire anyone. You may be passed over for a job because, by their standards,
youre merely 95% qualified.
Strategy: Acknowledge the areas in which you dont fit the profile. Instead of
focusing on your deficiencies, highlight your qualifications. If the position is outside
of your current industry, point out areas of similarity in which you have experience. Talk
about learning new skills and your ability to adapt; cite examples from past jobs when you
were thrust into new areas and how you performed.
Some employers give new employees little more than a job description, an office and a
list of interoffice phone numbers and leave them on their own. When this happens, you run
the risk of committing some otherwise avoidable faux pas, whether its as innocent as
using the CEOs coffee cup or as damaging as unknowingly insulting the companys
biggest client. You may wind up leaving the company frustrated and disillusioned.
Strategy: Be proactive and meet with key co-workers in and outside your department.
Ask your hiring manager to develop a plan to assimilate you into the organization. Spend
more time listening than talking during your first several months. Find mentors in the
organization who will give you honest feedback and information.
If you were recruited by a search firm, enlist its assistance in making your
transition. Chances are the recruiters spent a great deal of time with your new company
and can provide information you need.
Making a meaningful connection with a potential employer can be difficult. An
invitation to interview wont guarantee youll be given a fair shot. If
youre working with recruiters, ask them to guide you through each step, from initial
contact through final transition. Knowing the possible hazards can smooth your job search
and help you achieve better results.
-- Mr. Salveson is a principal of Salveson Stetson Group Inc., an executive search
firm in Wayne, Pa.