Are you having trouble getting your manager to buy into your ideas? You
can't put your finger on the problem. All you know is you're not getting credit
for what you do right and you're being overlooked for plum assignments.
If this scenario sounds familiar, the problem may be your inability to
communicate with your boss on his or her terms. This is what's known as a
failure to "manage up."
Managing up is strategically working with the style and goals of another,
blending them with your styles and goals to achieve results and accomplish your
career objectives. In other words, you need to speak the same language and to
focus on the factors that matter to the person you want to influence.
This is essential to career success regardless of your position in a
company. No matter how high up the ladder you are, at some point, you'll come
across a boss or client who's difficult to relate to or influence.
Clashing With the General Manager
A senior manager with 20 years at a California transportation company was
knowledgeable about his industry and had a strong relationship with the
company's former general manager. When the new GM came in, things took a turn
for the worse. The executive struggled to communicate with his new boss and
gain acceptance for his ideas. His career at the company began to flounder, and
he feared losing his job.
The problem was that the two executives had opposite management styles. The
GM had a visionary/creative style, while the manager had a logic-based style.
As a visionary/creative, the GM valued exchanging creative ideas,
brainstorming, discussing the big picture, exploring all possibilities, seeing
things in shades of gray, focusing on the goal, moving quickly on action items
and being No. 1.
When listening to presentations, he disliked getting mired in the
nitty-gritty details. He wanted the top and bottom line, without long
explanations about how the concept would be implemented. Subordinates also
needed to frame ideas in positive terms. To visionary/creatives, the phrase
"it can't be done" doesn't exist.
The manager's logic-based style was totally different. He preferred lots of
data and to focus on process, methodically and carefully drilling down into
problems, seeing things in black-and-white, right-and-wrong terms. When he
heard ideas, he'd ask "who," "what," "why,"
"where," "when" and "how" because of his desire
for more information. To ensure he had grasped a concept, he'd play devil's
advocate to explore what might not work.
It's easy to see how the two managers would have trouble connecting. To save
his job, the manager needed to define and understand his GM's style against his
own. He sought help from a management trainer. They developed a
game plan to help him package and communicate his ideas and tap into goals that
were more aligned with the GM's visionary/creative style.
To gain the GM's support, he learned to express himself using
"headline" and "bullet point" statements rather than
detailed analyses and to always offer a solution when discussing a problem. He
worked on his tone of voice so he appeared more assured and confident, and he
got his "devil's advocate" to take a hike. Since the GM's style is
conversational, the manager also started making small talk about nonbusiness
issues before launching into business problems.
Leverage the Plusses
You may be thinking, "Isn't this just selling out?" Actually, by
managing up, you're being strategic. Each style has benefits and drawbacks. The
trick is seeing and leveraging the benefits by speaking the local language, and
mitigating the drawbacks by reserving judgment about a particular style. Other
management styles include ego/driven, action/doer, relationship and
detail/perfection. Everyone uses a combination of these styles, but typically
relies mainly on one or two of them, so it helps to know their characteristics.
"[Managing up] sounds simple, but managers, and everyone else, need to
learn this basic concept," says Richard L. Knowdell, author of
"Building a Career Development Program: Nine Steps for Effective
Implementation," (Davies Black, 1996). " If we want someone to understand
what we have to say, we must learn to speak their language, rather than to
expect them to learn ours."
These additional tips can help you to manage up effectively:
1. Don't expect your boss to change.
You may have fantasized about getting your boss to change. You can influence
how you're coached or managed, but strategizing about how to get your boss to
change is futile. You have control only over yourself, your behavior and how
you're perceived. Managing up is about how you can act and communicate
to achieve your goals.
2. Include your manager's goals when presenting ideas.
Start by knowing the types of goals to pay attention to. To a manager, these
include any ideas or actions that improve the bottom line or profits. When you
present a new idea, always show how it will either save or make money for the
company. Also ask yourself, "How will my idea benefit my manager, the
team, the organization and/or the customer?" and "How will my idea
support the strategic vision of the company?"
Next, determine what else matters to your manager, whether it's customer
satisfaction, quality, continuous improvement, professional development for
staff, on-time delivery, or personally moving up the corporate ladder, and
speak to those issues.
3. Be aware of your manager's "hot buttons."
What are your manager's "hot buttons" or "pet peeves"?
Is it being late to meetings, incorrect spelling and grammar, swearing, or not
contributing at meetings? Consider them land mines. If you don't learn to
recognize them, you'll commit career suicide without knowing it.
4. Don't get blindsided. Solicit feedback often.
Feedback can be a gift if you can learn from it. The transportation manager
sought the GM's feedback every few weeks on how he was doing. Luckily, the GM
had no problem providing it. He saw noticeable improvement. By seeking feedback
and becoming effective at managing up, the manager kept his job and learned to
adapt to other styles as well.
During her five years with a small credit-screening company in Seattle, an
upper-level manager gained the respect of her bosses and increased amounts of
responsibility. She was asked to run a newly created department. Under her
management, its revenues fueled the company's growth for the next two years.
Her staff grew to 15 from two employees.
One day, the president called her in to tell her about feedback he had
received about her from department employees. They had told him she behaved
like a "dictator." The manager was devastated. She thought she was
well-respected and had performed well. This feedback came as a blow. Granted,
her boss could have described her behavior instead of labeling her personally.
But since the manager now sought advice, the focus remained on her.
An outside consultant recommended that she have
a heart-to-heart talk with her team about the issues, listen to how they viewed
her and then take action. Her employees told the manager that her tone of voice
was harsh and she tended to "tell" them to do things instead of
asking. She learned to moderate her voice and make requests instead of giving
orders.
The manager also asked that employees come to her directly with their
concerns. She's now in charge of a new department.
5. Manage up in client relationships.
Managing up also is relevant with clients. Recently, a training firm was
hoping to win a company CEO as a prospective client. The CEO's style was
visionary/creative with a strong splash of brash humor. During the contract
negotiations, the training consultants kept reinforcing how they could help him
achieve his vision for the company. They also bantered with him and even
included a few irreverent comments in the proposal. They got the project for
their ability to provide high-quality training and their willingness to relate
to him on his terms.
6. Increase your visibility within the organization.
Executives sometimes rebel against this concept. They say, "What if I
get a reputation as a toady or a bragger?" But if you aren't comfortable
showcasing your strengths and accomplishments, why should you expect anybody
else to be?
Your actions to gain visibility are like product marketing. When you go to
the grocery store, there are thousands of products to buy. When quality
differences are minimal, we often select items that have been marketed
effectively. One could argue the same goes for professionals vying to advance
within an organization.
Kathie Sinor, manager of leadership and teams for Sun University at Sun
Microsystems Inc., knew that gaining visibility among managers in other
departments was critical to her success at Sun and would help her to do her job
better. Working on team assignments helped her gain the exposure she needed
throughout the company and with her manager. For instance, she put extra
emphasis on a team assignment for an Asia-Pacific conference and "scored
big points when the event was successful," she says.
If you feel underappreciated during performance reviews, you may need to
boost your visibility. Just like products at the store, you have seconds to
make an impression. Make it easy for your boss to appreciate you and buy what
you're offering.
7. Manage up and down.
Some managers either pay attention to managing only their direct reports or
their own bosses. You may be thinking, "It's those pesky folks who only
manage up who can give managing up a less-than-wonderful reputation."
Successful managers pay attention to all directions. If you only manage down,
you can't advocate for your team and gain buy-ins for its endeavors. If you
only manage up, your subordinates will assume you don't care about them and
withhold their respect.
To manage up, you don't have to downplay your knowledge, skills and
ability to get results. Instead, you can integrate your approach with your
manager's to secure short- and long-term career success. This isn't selling
out. It's strategic.