FARGO, N.D. -- It's never been easy for Fargo, described by a former
economic-development director as "the least photogenic place in America."
The 1996 hit movie "Fargo" didn't help, depicting a desolate wasteland of
harsh winds, hip-deep snow and graphic violence.
But this metropolitan area of 175,000 is showing that business
opportunities in the frigid tundra can be surprisingly hot. As most of the
nation struggles to shake off the recession, Fargo's economy has stayed
strong and steady, attracting investment, adding jobs and extending a
decade of prosperity.
Now, Fargo is facing the opposite problem that much of the nation has:
It's starting to run out of workers.
Employers increasingly have to look elsewhere to fill openings -- and
attracting them to Fargo isn't easy. When out-of-state prospects balk at
the thought of Dakota winters, Candice Dietz, president of Fargo employment
agency Preference Personnel, counters by offering to throw in a snowmobile
or two. "Haven't had any takers," she says.
In October, the latest figures available, Fargo posted the
second-lowest
unemployment rate of any metro area in the nation, 1.8%, less than a third
of the national average. Employment here grew 5% between January and October
2002, compared to 2% job growth nationwide.
How did Fargo attract so many employers? After all, it lies in a region
considered so hopeless 15 years ago that a pair of professors recommended
the federal government turn it into a buffalo preserve.
Local leaders had no illusions that the climate and scenery were going
to sell their community. So while most midsize cities spent the 1990s
pitching hard-to-define "quality of life" to recruit companies, Fargo
promoted the quantity and quality of its labor force.
Local business groups financed detailed surveys that not only pinpointed
a skilled work force (more than 40% with two-year college degrees or
better, compared with 30% nationally), but also demonstrated that these
workers were readily available. The first surveys, conducted in the early
1990s, showed that within a 30-mile radius of Fargo, some 45,000 people
were "underemployed," many in low-paying jobs for which they were
overqualified, and that they were eager to offer their farm-bred work ethic
if given a better opportunity.
Companies bought the pitch. Cargill Inc., the
Minneapolis-based conglomerate, says local employees have proved so
productive and able to adapt to technology that it has been able to run its
Fargo accounting center with half the 250 employees it originally estimated
when it located here in the mid-1990s. Navigation Technologies Inc., a
Chicago-based maker of digital maps, says the productivity of its North
Dakota workers helped persuade it to shut down production in Sunnyvale,
Calif., last year and consolidate operations in Fargo.
SEI Information Technology Inc., a technical support firm, also of
Chicago, has more than doubled its Fargo work force over the past 18 months
to 275 and plans to add 25 more jobs by the end of the year.
Manufacturing employment in Fargo has grown by 1,000 jobs since 1995,
and continues to expand while U.S. factory jobs decline. In October, Marvin
Windows & Doors Inc. of Warroad, Minn., announced it would open a
second plant in Fargo, adding up to 100 jobs to a cluster of window makers
and suppliers that already employs about 800.
But success is gobbling up the very resource that launched it. Two years
ago, a work-force survey showed that the number of underemployed had
plunged to 13,000 -- just barely above the 12,000 jobs existing employers
estimated they would need to fill in a few years. Meantime, the rural
counties that have long replenished Fargo's labor pool are drying up as
young people leave the state to escape struggling farm economies: The
20-to-34-year-old group shrunk 23% in North Dakota in the '90s, compared
with 5% nationally.
The looming labor shortage has become such a concern that voters
considered a ballot measure earlier this month to give tax breaks and
$1,000 annual student-loan payments to young workers who stay in the state.
Opposed by much of the political and business establishment, the measure
failed, but recruiting workers remains near the top of the state's agenda.
The state legislature appropriated $237,500 last year to help lure talent,
some of which helps support
NorthDakotahasjobs.com, a Web site listing jobs at North Dakota companies. Gov. John
Hoeven even telephones certain people considering jobs in the state and
urges them to accept.
Dakota expatriates are a particular recruiting target. As opportunities
improve, political and business leaders hope they will return.
Michael Olsen, a Fargo native, thought he would never come back when he
left the state in the early '80s to work as a senatorial aide in
Washington, and later for a public-relations firm in Minneapolis. But a few
years ago, he made a business trip to Fargo to visit a potential client,
Great Plains Software, a home-grown company. Instead of luring Great Plains
as a client, Great Plains lured him: Chief Executive Doug Burgum recruited
Mr. Olsen to run the company's corporate communications. Mr. Olsen jumped
at an opportunity he thought he would never see: working for a growing,
international company and living in North Dakota. "Kids, we're going home,"
he told his children, who had never lived in the state.
It's a tougher sell for non-natives. Karen Edwards, an Illinois native,
says she was happy in Houston, when her husband, Jeff, told her Great
Plains was recruiting him for a job. She asked where the job was. He said
it was a great company. She asked again where the job was. He said it would
be a great opportunity. She asked where the job was a third time. "Fargo,"
her husband said. Ms. Edwards started laughing.
Ultimately, Great Plains -- now called Microsoft Business Solutions
since Microsoft Corp. bought it for $1.1
billion last year -- offered a job to Ms. Edwards, too. After a visit, she
agreed that Fargo would be the right place to raise a family, with its good
schools, friendly people, low cost of living and little crime. In March
2000, they moved to Fargo to take jobs as marketing executives. They have
renovated a century-old home and are living a "really, really nice life,"
says Ms. Edwards. She adds: "We look at it as the next adventure in our
lives. We don't know anybody else who packed up and moved to Fargo."
Community and business leaders concede that Fargo isn't for everyone,
but insist that if the local economy can provide good jobs, the area will
continue to attract people like Mr. Olsen and the Edwardses -- and persuade
more of the 20,000 college students in area to stay after graduation. That
is, as long as companies don't get cold feet about moving to Fargo or
expanding their operations here because they fear they can't find enough
workers -- a challenge Fargo so far has managed to overcome.
"People have made a career predicting the doom and gloom of the
prairies, but there are tremendous opportunities" says Joseph Chapman,
president of North Dakota State University in Fargo. Besides, the winters
really aren't that bad, adds a dead-serious Fargo Mayor Bruce Furness: "We
only get one week of 35 below."